Written by Li-Jung Wang and the Taiwan Association of Cultural Policy Studies.
Image credit: Cultural Policy Watch.
Following Part I of the article, Part II discusses the monitoring and evaluation of cultural policy implementation and consequence.
Priorities for Continued Monitoring and Evaluation
Although candidates have announced relevant proposals, professional associations and arts and cultural organisations should continue to monitor six interconnected dimensions: resource allocation, implementation arrangements, funding, timelines, public participation, and subsequent policy impacts.
A primary concern is whether the rules governing resource allocation are clearly defined and equitable. The intended beneficiaries of current cultural policy platforms include children and families, young creators, arts groups, residents of remote areas, and Indigenous and Hakka communities. Identifying beneficiary groups, however, must be accompanied by an explanation of how resources will be distributed. Universal provision, allocation by lottery, and needs-based cultural voucher schemes produce different patterns of benefit. Eligibility requirements, selection criteria, and the duration of access to arts spaces also affect whether small groups can obtain support. Touring programmes in remote areas must take account of transport, scheduling, and access to information to establish whether services actually reach residents.
Equitable allocation must also be supported by clear implementation arrangements and an explicit division of institutional responsibilities. Current platforms propose a range of instruments, including cultural vouchers, venue construction, rent-free spaces, the development of arts groups, non-departmental public bodies, and interdepartmental cooperation. Chen Ying’s original music hub, for instance, includes support for creation, recording, and release, alongside a proposal for operation by a non-departmental public body. Chang Chia-chun’s art museum proposal incorporates an interdepartmental platform, citizen curating, and university partnerships. These proposals go beyond general statements of intent. For the instruments to function in practice, however, candidates must specify which agencies will lead, which will collaborate, who will bear operating costs, and how implementation problems will be addressed.
Financial transparency is equally essential, particularly because campaign platforms often present funding commitments that differ substantially in their sources, purposes, and timeframes. Financial figures in cultural policy platforms represent different categories, including additional budget allocations, existing expenditure, approved central government subsidies, estimated construction costs, and targets for budget increases. They cannot simply be added together or directly compared. Building a cultural venue requires a one-off capital investment, while its subsequent operation entails annual expenditure on professional staff, exhibitions, equipment maintenance, and public services. Cultural voucher costs must be estimated on the basis of the number of beneficiaries, the amount provided per person, and administrative expenses, with clarification of whether funding will be allocated annually. Financial analysis should therefore establish the source of funds, expenditure categories, funding period, and approval status.
In addition, policy evaluation must distinguish between the initiation of service delivery and long-term objectives. Time commitments in campaign platforms operate at different levels. Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) Chiayi City mayoral candidate Chang Chi-kai’s proposal to convene an initial meeting of local government leaders within 100 days of taking office sets a deadline for initiating a cooperative mechanism. Annual cultural voucher quotas specify the scale of service provision. The 2035 target in Chang Chia-chun’s Hakka policy proposals expresses a long-term vision. These commitments should not be treated as equivalent promises of completion. Evaluation should separately establish when planning will begin, when residents will gain actual access to services, and which tasks will be completed within the term of office.
Another important dimension concerns the extent to which public participation translates into meaningful decision-making authority. Some proposals include cultural forums, citizen curating, informed consent by Indigenous communities, youth participation, and public reporting on cooperative initiatives. For example, Lin Kuo-chang proposes a cultural forum and white paper; Su Chiao-hui proposes mechanisms for Indigenous youth and tribal participation; and Wu Pin-jui and Chang Chi-kai’s proposals for Chiayi County–City cooperation include public progress reporting. These measures provide a basis for assessing transparency and participation in cultural governance. However, further clarification is needed regarding how participants will be selected, which matters they can decide, and how the government will respond to their views. The authority of Indigenous communities, ethnic groups, and local cultural communities over cultural interpretation, data use, and resource allocation also requires explicit clarification.
Regular Review of Key Indicators
Finally, monitoring should extend beyond campaign promises and initial implementation to evaluate the subsequent impacts of cultural policies. This requires a systematic process that combines measurable indicators, regular reviews, official documentation, and the experiences of those affected by the policies. Monitoring should include eligibility requirements, available places, geographical distribution, and actual service users.
To establish a consistent basis for comparison, there should be combined scheduled reviews with updates on significant developments. A pre-election baseline should document the original wording of commitments and distinguish new proposals from existing policies and long-term visions. A review 100 days after the administration takes office should identify lead agencies, work plans, and budgetary arrangements. This is a monitoring milestone rather than a requirement that all policies be completed within 100 days. Quarterly updates should examine regulations, grants, procurement, construction, and service delivery. An annual evaluation should integrate budget allocations, final accounts, service data, and user feedback. Comprehensive mid-term and end-of-term reviews should assess interim commitments and continuing operations. Significant developments, including budget cuts, policy changes, major delays, or venue openings, should trigger additional updates.
Such evaluations should draw on both official records and the lived experiences of cultural workers, communities, and service users. Relevant evidence includes government implementation plans, budgets and final accounts, council questioning, grant guidelines and recipient lists, procurement and acceptance records, venue annual reports, meeting minutes, and audit reports. Press releases can provide leads that are subsequently checked against relevant documentation. In addition, annual interviews or other forms of feedback collection should gather the experiences of creators, arts groups, local communities, and service users, including unsuccessful applicants and non-users. For example, an evaluation should record situations in which a space has opened but its application procedures, opening hours, or equipment fail to meet users’ needs. Public reporting on beneficiaries should primarily use aggregated statistics to protect personal information.
Monitoring findings should be used to elicit responses and improvements. A brief quarterly update can explain what has been completed, which activities have been delayed, and which information remains unavailable. Specific questions concerning omissions or inconsistencies should be directed to the responsible agencies, with the dates and substance of their responses retained.
Finally, these findings should also be consolidated into an annual report that provides a broader assessment of policy implementation and its consequences. The annual report should assess the extent to which commitments have been fulfilled, examine the distribution of resources, and identify institutional arrangements requiring adjustment. This approach would allow the existing database to develop from a pre-election comparison of platforms into an ongoing record of cultural governance throughout the term of office.
The Association recommends that civil society organisations and research institutions use pre-election commitments as a baseline, update implementation progress quarterly, and assess resource allocation and policy effects annually, incorporating the experiences of creators, local communities, and service users. Whether a policy has been initiated, whether residents have benefited, and whether conditions for creative work have improved should be reported separately.
This review is limited to the publicly available policy materials collected to date. Some information still requires supplementation and verification, and the absence of a proposal from the dataset does not indicate that a candidate has no relevant position. The Association calls on candidates to continue publishing complete proposals so that their cultural policy platforms become public commitments that can be scrutinised, shaped through participation, and continuously improved after the election.
Dr. Li-Jung Wang is a Professor in the Department of Hakka Language and Social Sciences and the Center for General Education at National Central University, Taiwan, where she also serves as Associate Vice President for Academic Affairs. Her interdisciplinary research specialises in cultural policy, ethnic and Hakka studies, cultural rights and citizenship, social media, digital literacy, and the impact of artificial intelligence on creative industries. Dr. Wang has published extensively in prominent international journals, including the International Journal of Cultural Policy and Citizenship Studies, and has authored multiple influential scholarly books and edited volumes on Taiwan’s cultural public sphere and multicultural governance.
Founded on May 16, 2015, the Taiwan Association of Cultural Policy Studies (TACPS) is an independent non-profit cultural think tank dedicated to fostering an open, democratic cultural public sphere. Bridging researchers, creative practitioners, and policymakers across diverse artistic fields, TACPS promotes participatory cultural governance, cultural democracy, and citizen cultural rights. Moving beyond state-centric frameworks, the Association serves as an external supervisory and collaborative mechanism for cultural policy, facilitating rigorous dialogue among civil society, public institutions, and cultural enterprises. Actively connecting local cultural insights with global networks across East Asia, Europe, and the Americas, TACPS is committed to structural cultural reform and elevating Taiwan’s international academic standing in cultural policy.
