How Taipei positions itself globally as a ‘green city’

Written by Leslie Mabon

Image credit: Community garden in Chenggong, Da’an District, Taipei. Photo taken by Leslie Mabon.

1) Why does knowledge-sharing matter for ecological cities?

The last decade or so has seen a proliferation of programmes and initiatives aimed at city-to-city networking for climate and sustainability action. Reducing emissions, adapting to extremes and slower-onset changes and conserving biodiversity – all while supporting the least well-off and sustaining the economy – are complex challenges. It is therefore not surprising that cities want to learn from each other. Indeed, strong evidence shows that local governments find participation in these networks valuable.

Ideas about what constitutes a green and sustainable city therefore do not arise in isolation, with policies and best practices travelling over space and time. However, the processes that share such knowledge are not value-neutral. Scholarship on so-called policy mobilities has its origins in urban and regional planning, and examines how ideas travel globally about how cities and regions ‘ought’ to respond to social and environmental challenges. Whose experiences urban sustainability networks include and exclude, and what they consider ‘best practice’ worthy of wider adoption may reflect particular ideas about how the economy ought to be run or what a resilient city should look like. Conversely, participation in global sustainability networks can also be a conscious choice cities and regions make when they aspire to greater international recognition and to position themselves on the global stage. I’ve previously written about how Taipei and Glasgow, for example, adopt the UN’s climate and sustainability language and carry a visible presence in global city networks despite the respective distance of Taiwan and Scotland from formal UN recognition.

All of these issues offer a valuable perspective on the question of what kinds of ‘ecological city’ are being imagined for Taipei, and by and for whom. Taking green and natural urban spaces as a focal point, in this article I want to focus on how Taipei participates in and positions itself within myriad international eco-city networks, and how this might be reflected in the ecological city initiatives that are promoted within Taipei.

2) Taipei’s participation in international urban knowledge networks

A first point to get clear is that when I refer to ‘Taipei’ here, I am referring to the wider city region – not only Taipei City, but also New Taipei City. Both Taipei and New Taipei City governments have a presence in global sustainability networks. While the two differ subtly, the nature and extent of their participation are broadly similar.

The participation of Taipei in international knowledge-sharing for urban development is not new. Unsurprisingly, it is also not uncontentious. Urban planning and development in Taipei was guided from the mid-1960s to the early 1970s by expertise from the United Nations, which had a dedicated advisory team stationed in Taipei. One of the most notable outcomes of this UN influence was the green and leafy Minsheng Community just south of Songshan Airport. The proliferation of parks and greenery in this neighbourhood stands as a very good example of how the in-flow of planning ideals from elsewhere – in this case from the UN – can influence how nature is protected and managed within a city.

Direct UN presence and guidance in Taipei abruptly ended in the early 1970s when Taiwan ceased to be a charter member of the UN, demonstrating how access to knowledge and expertise, which can shape the urban environment, is inseparable from global geopolitics. Such issues continue to influence the nature of Taiwanese cities’ participation in international networks to the present day. For instance, the Global Covenant of Mayors for Climate and Energy – a worldwide coalition of city leaders addressing climate change, supported by a combination of existing city networks and UN bodies – in 2020 listed Taipei and New Taipei, plus four other Taiwanese municipalities, as part of China. Following protestations, the Global Covenant agreed to recognise the six municipalities under the designation of ‘Chinese Taipei’. Whilst this incident has ultimately not hampered the ability of Taipei to participate in the Global Covenant of Mayors for Climate and Energy, it does again illustrate how Taiwan’s geopolitical status can influence the conditions under which Taiwanese cities are able to connect with their peers globally on a breadth of environmental and sustainability issues, including urban nature. As I have argued elsewhere, when it comes to sharing best practices on local responses to climate, biodiversity and sustainability challenges, naming and correct recognition matters if one is to understand the governance and socio-economic context that enables specific actions to happen.

3) Taipei and Taiwanese cities’ global participation

Contestations over naming aside, global urban and city-region networks do enable planners and environmental managers within Taiwan to participate in peer to peer learning with other cities globally. This can be a fruitful opportunity for alliance-building, which arguably enables fuller participation than Taiwan can achieve at the national level.

One good example of this, albeit not from Taipei, is the ICLEI Kaohsiung Capacity Center. This is an initiative jointly run by the City of Kaohsiung and ICLEI Local Governments for Sustainability, an international non-governmental organisation promoting sustainable urban development. One of the most notable achievements of the ICLEI Kaohsiung Capacity Center is to put Kaohsiung at the centre of a network of 15 cities spanning Asia, Europe and North America, who can learn from each other through a series of workshops and peer learning events. The centre’s activities have a strong emphasis on the planning and enhancement of urban nature to adapt to climate change impacts and support biodiversity conservation, and involve Kaohsiung learning from good practices globally as well as sharing its own positive experiences of planning urban tree cover to reduce risk to the most vulnerable people from extreme heat. As such, urban planners and environmental managers in Kaohsiung can tap into global expertise on how urban nature can best support people under an increasingly volatile climate, arguably bypassing the scale of the nation-state and working directly with other cities worldwide.

However, it is important to reiterate a point of caution. Simply participating in or being recognised in these international fora does not mean Taipei and indeed other Taiwanese cities will be able to learn and adapt practices that provide the most equitable responses to complex environmental and social challenges; nor does it mean the practices Taiwanese cities share are inherently good. Nciri and Levenda (2020) warn of a ‘sustainability fix’ in urban policy, whereby globally shared best practices may promote existing growth-orientated interests under the status quo whilst masquerading as being sustainable. In short, it is important not to over-celebrate instances where the ecological city actions of Taipei and other Taiwanese cities are recognised globally, and retain a healthy scepticism over the grounds on which these initiatives may be considered a success story and whose vision of an ecological city they represent.

Taipei’s experiences with small-scale green spaces over the last decade or so provide a strong example in this regard. The apparent proliferation of greenery at sites across the city may appear to be a positive, and has been acknowledged by bodies such as ICLEI and the American Chamber of Commerce in Taiwan. It is at base hard to argue against the expansion of urban nature as a positive. However, what is sometimes missing from international accounts of urban greening in Taipei are the limitations or contestations that accompany the varying ecological city-related programmes that have taken place in the city. For instance, the Taipei Beautiful programme in the early 2010s incentivised property owners to demolish buildings and implement green spaces, yet faced critical backlash due to the fact that the newly-implemented green spaces could be redeveloped after only 18 months. More recently, the Taipei Garden City initiative allowed community gardens to be established on publicly-owned lands. Again, whilst this has undoubtedly been a positive in terms of fostering neighbourhood connectivity, it is also the case that communities are often only able to use the land on a temporary basis, and may remain at the mercy of being evicted from the sites when the time comes for them to be developed.

These high-level greening initiatives within Taipei could therefore be viewed as a ‘sustainability fix’ if they are shared and received internationally as examples of how to effectively enhance green coverage in a city, without acknowledging the continued dominance of private sector developers and top-down decision-making in the urban governance process. This may become particularly problematic if such programmes continue to gain attention and traction to the detriment of genuine locally-driven urban greening actions within Taipei, such as the ‘guerilla gardening’ approaches to appropriating vacant urban space which sprung up before and around the time of the 2014 Sunflower Movement. Even within municipally-led initiatives such as Taipei Garden City and Taipei Open Green, a programme that provided public funds in response to community-led renovation proposals for open space, it is crucial not to overlook the role academics, landscape consultants and grassroots activists played in initiating and shaping these programmes.

4) Summing up

City networks and peer-to-peer sharing offer one way for Taipei – and Taiwan’s cities more widely – to continue to form alliances in the face of continued geopolitical pressure faced by Taiwan at a national level. Yet, these networks themselves are not neutral, and practices that are circulated as examples of ‘what works’ are often shared for a reason. As actors in Taiwan – right up to the level of the President – begin to emphasise on urban greening and urban forestry as a climate change adaptation strategy, there is therefore a need for continued scrutiny as to what is promoted globally as a success story, by whom, and on what grounds.

Leslie Mabon is a Senior Lecturer in Environmental Systems at the School of Engineering and Innovation at the Open University. He is an environmental social scientist, with particular interest in whose evidence and knowledge is included – and why – in decision-making about the environment. Leslie has been researching environmental issues in Taiwan, especially urban greenspace planning and governance, for over a decade. You can read more about his work at https://resilientcoastal.zone or on BlueSky/X @ljmabon

Leave a Reply